Here's the trick: Use black liner first and smudge it, make sure to put it in the corners and water line. Next, go over the liner with a dark charcoal color, make sure it's a slightly shimmery one (You don't want to be Ke$ha, that's for sure, you just want it shimmery enough to really lighten up your eyes). Use a fuller brush to spread the charcoal color into your far corners (make sure to clean it up well if you're going outside of your eyebrow line) and into your crease. Next, use a gold shade and dust it lightly into the inside corners and blend it well with the charcoal. With a blending brush, use small, circular strokes to blend it all together. Add some of the gold to the bottom lid, and a highlight under the brows if desired. Finish with 2 coats of a volumizing mascara (I like Maybelline Falsies and Cover Girl Lashblast Fusion) clean up any mistakes and you're good to go!